Gavin Bard

LightFantastic

LightFantastic

Video Game Journalists Are Spineless

Video Game Journalists Are Spineless

Posted by: LightFantastic

Posted: 2009-11-12

I hate to weigh in on something that everybody else in this industry is going to write some hit generating cop out article for, but I just can't sit by and watch this nonsense happening without making a knee-jerk argument against it. First, to honor full disclosure, I should let you all know something.

I shot every single civilian I could in "No Russian." Every. Single. One. Did I do it because I'm some sick freak who loves watching innocent people die? Of course not. Did I do it because Infinity Ward put that in the game for a reason in order to tell a narrative and, out of respect to them and their artistic vision I should play it? Partly. Mostly I spilled the blood of every poor little ragdoll because the people whining about this scene are so outrageously hypocritical that I felt it was my duty to shoot these innocent lines of code just to spite them.

My problem here isn't that the Jack Thompson's of the world are going to rail against this game for how far across the line it apparently stepped. That always happens. People who don't understand video games or want to place blame for terrible parenting or just plain crazy people doing terrible things are always going to gravitate towards video games because it is an interactive medium and they don't understand it. They are like your grandparents trying to text message you. This is nothing new and it doesn't even bother me anymore.

What does bother me, nay infuriates me, is reading gamers and, even worse, video game journalists and people within the industry joining these people in their outrage. Maybe this just pisses me off more than most people because of my well known pretentious views on gaming journalism, or how I feel video games should be considered as much of an art form as anything else. Maybe this all just pisses me off because it made me so angry I had to look like a hypocrite myself by writing an article about video game journalism even though I've already mentioned how annoying I find it when games journalists write about games journalism. This is my soap box though, and I'll do what I want.

The problem I have with people from our side of the line whining about this like a bunch of misguided soccer moms is that these hypocrites have most likely at one point either A) complained about censorship in games or, even worse than that, B) done articles about how video games should be considered equals with movies and television. This is why these people should have their licenses revoked from video game commentary. If video games should be held equal, then why aren't you writing articles about how outraged you were that an entire city got nuked in 24? Or how about all the innocent people that get gunned down in Battlestar Galactica? Isn't that crossing a line too if Modern Warfare is? All entertainment is created equal, right?

It is ridiculous to see colleagues who preach that video games are no longer a mindless diversion just for kids and can be used to address serious issues or even be considered works of art all of a sudden lose their spine when it comes to this. Whats even worse is that they are undermining the games journalism industry by doing it. My predominant theory is that these people, I won't name names but I'm sure you've read their commentary and articles, smell hits like sharks to a bleeding whale. Of course most gaming journalists are going to say this is "nbd" and par for the course and, hopefully, have a similar opinion to me. But these divas, these jellyfish who seem to suddenly think video games can't be a difficult commentary on real life, know that by going against the grain people will go and read their insipid and hypocritical viewpoint.

Video games aren't just mindless escapism anymore. They can be entirely engrossing, conflicting, intelligent narratives on any number of subjects. They should be taken as equal with any other form of entertainment or statement. To undermine it in the name of getting some cheap hits is sickening. What is even worse is the alternative that some journalists and gamers in this industry really ARE unintelligent hypocrites who want to put on their Moral White Knight Guy Fawkes mask and rail away at the idea of shooting a few innocents in a video game right before they go to the movies and watch Gerard Butler cut a swath of destruction through Philadelphia. It scares me that these people don't realize how hypocritical they actually are.

So, moral of the story, you can't have your cake and eat it too. If you want games to be taken seriously as a medium for artistic expression and entertainment, you are going to have to deal with video games actually addressing serious things. If not, well, I guess you can always review puzzle games.

Or maybe those would be too challenging for you too.

 

User comments [3]

8 months, 2 weeks ago Gavin Bard [blog]
LightFantastic

See Lewis, that makes sense but I think it is a much different arguement than what is annoying me. Because me and you could have a debate on the artistic merits of the scene and the reason it was included. I'm talking about the people who are just blanketly offended for the sake of being offended- the journalists and gamers who are suddenly morally opposed to gunning down innocents. I personally find the scene entirely less bothering than anything you can do in GTA. In GTA you can mow down innocent people in hundreds of ways in an entirely casual and light hearted way. I thought the scene was powerful and helped frame not only the plot but also the antagonist. Artistically speaking I don't think it was unnecessary at all.

Plus, I enjoy the fact that nobody has any problem playing as the Germans in a WW2 game and killing Americans. Or any war game in general and killing armed soldiers who aren't necessary terrorists, but this scene has become some sort of divisive watershed in the community.

The only thing I patently disagree with you on in your article is the idea that something can ever be pushed too far. There is no such thing as too far in art. A movie can use 9/11 as a set piece, TV can make jokes about WW2 concentration camps, comics can use rape and murder as a reason to have a character put a spandex suit on and fight crime. Video games are in the same category, or at least should be.

My issue isn't so much that people are offended, obviously this is going to be a delicate subject, my issue is with the people who are offended and say something like "video games should be escapism" or "video games should stay out of politics or serious territory like this" because it suddenly serves their point. That is just damn right offensive.

And, just for comparison, I think the scene in first last Modern Warfare game where you are controlling the soldier slowly dying after the nuclear bomb goes off to be ten times more disturbing than the no russian scene and that flew entirely under the radar on the controversy scale.

8 months, 2 weeks ago Lewis Denby [blog]
Lewis

What about journalists who have always rallied for properly mature content in games and continue to do so, but who feel that because of the way the scene was implemented in the game, it felt more like war porn than something trying to make an actual statement, and were offended as such?  I think that's a totally reasonable stance to have.My stance is this, incidentally: http://thedailyscoundrel.com/2009/11/12/games-modern-warfare-2-no-mercy-for-no-russian/

8 months, 2 weeks ago Diarmuid Bourke [blog]
diarmuidbourke

Very well said! I'm sick of people thinking games should always be about arranging barbie dolls and not addressing engrossing current day events and stories.

Got an opinion? Sharing is caring so put it out there!

Why not comment on this article?. But first, sign up for a Faceoff Games account - it is real easy and besides there's lots of benefits:

  • You can win money playing video games against gamers in head to head matches for a start.
  • Or play in one of our Faceoff Games’ tournaments for the chance to win a big cash payout.
  • You can write your own blog, detailing how you made a fortune or whatever takes your fancy Awee yeah.
  • Plus you can buy games in the shop to home your skills and have some fun.
  • There’s a kicking social network, bonuses and more – check it out today!